Grade 10 Geography Exam on Xenophobia Attack Draws Backlash

A Grade 10 Geography exam paper describing a xenophobic attack has drawn strong backlash online, with critics accusing it of one-sided indoctrination.

The paper describes the assault of a character named John and poses questions on terms such as hatred toward foreign nationals, the differences between refugees and illegal immigrants, reasons for South African resentment amid high unemployment and job competition, and ways to curb violence.

Images of the paper circulated on social media, prompting criticism that it overlooks migration’s economic impacts and border control issues. Some commentators, particularly in the Western Cape, argued the questions frame the debate in a way that discourages broader discussion of immigration policy.

The controversy reflects ongoing xenophobic tensions in cities including Johannesburg and Durban, where recent protests have led to evacuations and deportations. The Department of Basic Education has not commented on the matter.

Supporters of the paper argued that it addresses a real social issue and encourages learners to think critically about violence and intolerance. Critics, however, insisted that exam materials should present balanced perspectives and avoid steering learners toward particular conclusions.

The debate has renewed questions about how sensitive social issues are handled in the classroom and whether exam papers are adequately reviewed for bias.

About The Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×